Sunday, March 26, 2017

Reaching for the Top - Another sign we are in the mania phase

Meet Larry and Adam Rachlin.

They're mortgage brokers in Ontario, and our newest poster children for the Canadian Housing Bubble.

Larry has Bachelor of Arts degree in Political Science & Speech Communication (honours) and is a 27 year veteran in mortgage financing and brokerage. He has an even longer tenure in the financial services industry including secured and unsecured funding, debt consolidation as well as personal & business tax preparation.

Adam is Seneca College graduate with a Diploma in Financial Services Underwriting. He's been in financial services for over 21 years including mortgage & loan underwriting, personal & business income tax preparation as well as commercial leasing & property management.

Together they run Mortgages Unlimited, a mortgage brokerage whose slogan is "We don't say 'NO', we offer an alternative."

Larry recently posted a youtube video (you can see it here) promoting their services and here is the opening pre-amble:
Every day someone calls and tells me they have an urgent cash crisis. 
They tell me nobody is able to help them, they're ready to give up. 
They say I'm their last hope. And I tell him this: I don't care if you have bad credit. I don't care if you can't prove income. I don't care if you have tax arrears or if you haven't filed an income tax return. Or even have mortgage arrears. I don't even care if you won't be able to make any payments for a while. 
All I require is that you have a good story and own a home that has some reasonable equity. If you have that, I'll get you the money you need. And I'll let you have up to 12 months with no monthly payments. Got a good story if so call me Larry Rachlin.
Your house is an ATM machine and all you need is a "good story".

Speaking of good stories, did you ever hear the one about the US housing crisis of 2008 and HELOC's?


Click 'comments' below to contribute to this post.

Please read disclaimer at bottom of blog.

Wednesday, March 22, 2017

Toronto's Condo King declares Canadian economy solely dependent on foreign buyers

Meet Brad Lamb. Faithful readers will recognize Lamb as Toronto's version of the Rainforest's Bob Rennie - aka 'the Condo King' of their respective cities.

If you haven't been keeping up, the centre of the universe has been awash in Lotusland Asian money overflow since the imposition of Krusty's 15% foreign buyers tax last September. Panic buying has gripped Toronto and suddenly there are calls from all corners for the Big Smoke to take BC style action and implement their own foreign buyers tax.

Of course all of this is curious since, just like Vancouver pre-tax, the local real estate industry has been adamant that Toronto house prices are not fuelled by foreign funds. In fact as recently as Jan 31, 2017 the Toronto Star newspaper noted the following denial by the Toronto Real Estate Board:
Don’t blame overseas investors for the high price of housing in the Toronto area, says the city’s real estate board. 
The Toronto Real Estate Board (TREB) released new research Tuesday showing only 4.9 per cent of the 113,133 residential real estate transactions in the Toronto region last year involved foreign buyers.
Now you would think that if only 4.9% of the market is impacted by foreign money, any discussion of a foreign buyers tax would be inconsequential to the industry.

But as political momentum gathers to implement just such a tax, the Condo King of Toronto comes out with a claim that utterly shreds the 4.9% narrative.

Today BNN reported that Lamb is publicly warning that "taxing foreign home buyers in the skyrocketing Toronto real estate market could trigger a national recession."
In an email sent to unit owners in his 17 buildings late Tuesday, Brad Lamb railed against the long-debated idea of a 15 per cent surcharge on buyers of Toronto properties who are not Canadian citizens or permanent residents; similar to the one imposed in Vancouver in August 2016. Boasting of having “eaten, drank, and slept the Toronto real estate marketplace for 30 years,” the CEO of Lamb Developments argues such a tax would be “an egregious error in policy.” 
“In Toronto… it could also precipitate a Canada-wide recession,” Lamb wrote near the start of his roughly 1,300-word note. 
“Kill the new condo market, kill the Ontario economy. Kill the Ontario economy and Canada falls too,” Lamb wrote.
The Toronto Real Estate Industry now joins their Vancouver counter parts in trying to move heaven and earth to politically intervene in public policy dealing with the massive malinvestment created by the worldwide excess credit epidemic.

In the process we get another glimpse at how the Real Estate Board's claims about the impact of foreign money is completely detached from what their members on the ground know all too well.


Click 'comments' below to contribute to this post.

Please read disclaimer at bottom of blog.

Tuesday, February 28, 2017

Scotiabank joins growing list of those issuing Real Estate bubble warnings

Well another day and it seems another senior mainstream finance wizard is shouting out warnings of impending doom in the overblown real estate market in our country.

Did all the bear bloggers somehow get outed as bank economists this month?

The latest is Scotiabank CEO Brian Porter who says the Toronto and Vancouver housing markets will have to correct at some point.

"Trees don't grow to the sky and markets will correct at some stage here,'' Porter told analysts Tuesday.

This comes on the heels of Bank of Montreal’s chief economist, Douglas Porter, stating,"Let’s drop the pretense. The Toronto housing market — and the many cities surrounding it — are in a housing bubble” and Sun Life’s Chief Investment Officer Sadiq Adatia who said,"eventually we are going to see this market kind of stop and then come off a cliff, the longer we stay in this run-up, the bigger the downturn is going to be.”

You really can't get much more specific that this for advice on where things are going.

Of course, if you want confirmation that everything's okay and you should 'buy, buy, buy' we turn to the real estate industry and Mark Renzoni, president of global commercial real estate giant CBRE.

Renzoni had just wrapped up a speech at the CBRE's annual Canadian Market Outlook attended by about 1,400 brokers, developers and landlords at the Toronto Convention Centre. Afterwards he gave an interview to the Toronto Star in which he did his Renzoni best Alfred E. Neuman impression and advised us:
Bubble. What bubble? 
Toronto's soaring home prices are in line with the reality of other world cities such as New York, Hong Kong and London, says Mark Renzoni, president of global commercial real estate giant CBRE .
"The market is fairly balanced. It's not being driven by foreign capital. It's being driven by Canadians, moving up, buying for the first time," he told the Star, following a speech at CBRE's annual market forecast event. 
"There's great jobs, there's a sense of optimism, there's confidence in the job market and interest rates are low," said Renzoni, who suggested that concerns about foreign speculation in the Toronto housing market are overblown.
So there you have it. And c'mon... let's face it. Those banking types, they're all closet wearing, tin foil hat sportin' doomers. Right?


Click 'comments' below to contribute to this post.

Please read disclaimer at bottom of blog.

Monday, February 27, 2017

A little more about that 'supply' argument...

As you will recall, in our last post we shared with you the above meme which we found in our in-box.

While it strikes a chord with your faithful scribes here at the Rainforest Roundtable, we do note a slight error in it.  The census data show 26K vacant housing units in Vancouver, not 26% of all housing.

But still... 26,000 is a lot.

The data comes from the 2016 Census which tells us that Vancouver saw a 15% increase in empty and non-resident units.

A "non resident" home is defined as either empty or occupied by a foreign or temporary resident. But most often, the units are empty. Of all the homes in the region that fall into the category, 87% are unoccupied, according to an Urban Futures report.

What agitates the locals is that a large part of the empty-home problem is speculative buying. Particularly speculative buying from foreign money - primarily Chinese money.

In Vancouver's downtown, the Coal Harbour neighbourhood is 22.2% empty or non-resident occupied, and the census tract east of it is 18.2%.

But other, less obvious Vancouver neighbourhoods also show signs of emptiness. Here is a chart showing the impact:

We have been bombarded in the last year with two major themes: the need to increase supply and increasing zoning density - particularly along transit routes.

Now if you know the Village on the Edge of the Rainforest, you are aware of Cambie Street.  Running north/south down the west side of the city, it is a very upper end part of the city.  Vancouver's latest subway, the Canada Line, was constructed underneath Cambie Street and links the Vancouver Airport with the downtown core.

Let's take a look at the south end of that area on this map, it is circled in blue here:

You will note that it has one of the highest percentage of unoccupied areas in the city, particularly the southernmost end.

Drive down Cambie Street today and you will notice oodles of for sale signs as sellers attempt to entice buyers looking to assemble parcels of land. Selling for $3-4 million per house, this is not a cheap prospect.  But once assembled, and rezoned, the financial jackpot is well worth the investment of buying up a block of houses.

Driving this, of course, is the off shore marketing of these properties to foreign speculative money (more on that in a future post).

And nothing epitomizes this speculative frenzy like the deepest red section at the bottom of the map:

This chunk of area is home to the Marine Gateway project constructed around the first Vancouver Canada Line Station as you enter coming from Richmond.  Marine Gateway was highly touted as a showcase solution to Vancouver's housing affordability crisis. Lower end units sold in the $350,000 range and were highly marketed as the new, urban solution for young buyers centred around the transit density development bandwagon.

Problem is that the 2016 Census shows that the Marine Gateway neighbourhood has a 24% non-resident rate (as does Joyce-Collingwood, another subway based urban-oriented transit hub). More significantly there are 609 empty or non-resident units in Marine Gateway Station development.

As noted in the Globe and Mail newspaper,
For many, empty or under-used homes are tangible proof of the commodification, or financialization, of housing. There are those who will argue that an increased supply is necessary to subdue the market, to remove the pressure of scarcity. However, housing markets in what Mr. Yan calls "hedge cities," such as Vancouver, are fuelled by an unprecedented wealth coming from outside. Without addressing the speculative nature of the market, how much effect will supply have?
Marine Gateway stands as a monument to... and proof that... creating extra supply will have no effect at all in dealing with scarcity.

Simply looking at the contrast pictures of downtown Vancouver at the top of this post is visual proof that increasing supply did nothing to resolve affordability by addressing scarcity.

The reality is that the 'supply' argument is a political wedge to leverage municipal politicians into rezoning neighbourhoods so developers can destroy single family homes in favour of condo stock to fuel and profit from the foreign speculative demand.

People are fed up with the pandering currently going on to an industry that only serves to destroy our community. The 'supply' argument is a red herring.  Following the money proves this point.


Click 'comments' below to contribute to this post.

Please read disclaimer at bottom of blog.

Sunday, February 26, 2017

About that 'Supply' Argument...

About the Development Community's 'Supply' argument that is bombarding Vancouver real estate news this past week... the meme says it all.


Click 'comments' below to contribute to this post.

Please read disclaimer at bottom of blog.

Friday, February 24, 2017

Vancouver Real Estate Housing Bubble Daily Review Videos

Just in case you haven't seen them yet, this Youtuber posts daily videos offering a quick review of news and items from Twitter. Range from 3-7 mins and seems like a neat summary of the news. You can find him on Twitter @VanRE_Week_Rev

Above is video for February 22 and below are February 23rd and 24th.


Click 'comments' below to contribute to this post.

Please read disclaimer at bottom of blog.

Wednesday, February 22, 2017

Two significant Vancouver court cases regarding Chinese money in Vancouver Real Estate

In case you missed them, there were two interesting articles written today by Ian Young, Vancouver correspondent for the South China Morning Post.

The first, in his "The Hongcouver" column (they say only Nixon could go to China... and only an Asian could get away with that title in today's PC world), headlines "A Vancouver firm offers clients 'new identities'. It's customers have included Chinese criminals"

It's news sure to add to Vancouver's reputation as a centre for laundering illegal money through our bubblicious Real Estate market.

Apparently a Vancouver firm, Amicus International Consulting, will provide clients “new legal identities” via new citizenships, passports and "plausible cover stories?"

One of Amicus' customers, which Young profiles, is Kuang Wan Fang. Writes Young:
Kuang’s husband, Xu Chaofan, and Yu’s husband, Xu Guojun, were involved in a massive scam to defraud their employer, the Bank of China, that lasted from 1991 until their arrest in the US in 2004. Together with a third BOC manager, they made off with at least US$485 million. They fled to the US via Vancouver, acquired US citizenship and laundered their cash through Canadian and Hong Kong banks, Macau and Las Vegas casinos, and the Vancouver and Toronto property markets. 
According to the US indictment that would lead to all being convicted, the fraudsters used the stolen cash to buy at least three Richmond mansions, on Udy Road and Mang Road, that are now valued at about C$9.5 million. 
According to Amicus, it helped get Kuang and Yu transferred into Spanish custody on September 23 and September 11, 2011, respectively; the US Federal Bureau of Prisons confirms that they did indeed leave US custody on those dates, although their destination is not listed. 
Kuang’s movements between 2011 and 2015 are unclear. In the meantime, the BC Supreme Court ruled on April 16, 2015, that Kuang should repay BOC the entire stolen sum, now valued at C$670 million, which the RCMP said had been hidden and dispersed among 14 relatives, many living in the Vancouver area, according to The Province newspaper’s account of the case.
$670 million? One assumes more than a couple of $5 million + homes on Vancouver's west side were acquired with that tidy sum.


Young follows that up with a second article, "In landmark ruling, Vancouver homebuyer is ordered to repay millions to China’s Citic Bank" in which we are told about Chinese mainlander Yan Shibiao.

It seems China’s Citic Bank has won a landmark judgment in a Canadian court against Yan Shibiao and has ordered him to repay the bank RMB50 million (US$7.3 million), plus interest, that the bank says was spent in part on real estate in Vancouver.

The fact that a mainland Chinese bank has won a judgement in a Canadian court is causing a massive stir on local Chinese online internet chat boards.

China has been working with Canada for years to finalise a deal on the return of ill-gotten assets seized from those suspected of economic crimes. The agreement was originally announced in July 2013 and has not yet been ratified.

But this case marks a turning point. It's rare for Chinese banks to use Canadian courts to pursue those who have left the country and it sends a chilling message to Chinese nationals in Canada on visitor's visa's (which was Yan's situation).

Vancouver lawyer Christine Duhaime, an anti-money-laundering expert who represents Citic and originally petitioned the BC court on the bank’s behalf last year, said the case “shows China and their banks that [Canadian asset] recovery is possible in the civil context”.
“There are so many more cases with similar facts of foreign nationals from China who owe vast amounts of debt in unpaid loans that are parked in other countries, that I suspect the floodgates will open to pursuing recovery of those debts. Much of that money is in Canada,” said Duhaime in an interview.
We wonder what west side realtor Tom Gradecak's thoughts might be on these developments?


Click 'comments' below to contribute to this post.

Please read disclaimer at bottom of blog.

Tuesday, February 21, 2017

Asian Cash Losing Its Cachet? A Vancouver Realtor offers comfort to Reuters American readers

On a day when all the local attention is focused on the release of the BC Provincial Budget, let's turn our attention to a small news item that probably slipped under your radar today. posted an article by Reuters news service titled "Chinese investors find their cash is losing its cachet".

Apparently China's tightening capital controls are beginning to be felt in North America as Chinese firms struggle to close deals owing to lack of FX. As a result,  overseas direct investment is dropping sharply.  North American sellers want Chinese buyers to provide proof of funds and such deal scrutiny is hurting investor confidence.

According to Reuters:
"Chinese investors have been highly sought after the world over. Now, their cash is losing its cachet. China's increasing efforts to prevent capital from leaving the country are eroding the confidence of domestic and foreign investors about getting deals done inside and outside of the world's second-biggest economy. Chinese bidders had become ubiquitous in deals in the past two years and were welcomed, said Severin Brizay, head of Europe, the Middle East and Africa mergers and acquisitions for the investment bank UBS. 'Clients were asking if it would be possible to make sure they are involved. Now, we are seeing the reverse: some clients are asking if we can do it without Chinese bidders because of the domestic challenges they face,' he said.
Those at the heart of brokering investment deals with Chinese investors say that many Chinese firms are unable to close deals because they can not secure official permission to transfer yuan into foreign exchange.

This, of course, follows a series of capital control measures China implemented late last year to tighten restrictions on capital outflows and rein in what officials have called "irrational" outbound investment.

The Institute of International Finance estimated capital outflows surged to a record $725 billion last year and it expects even higher outflows this year. The yuan fell more than 6.5% last year against the US dollar, its steepest decline since 1994, prompting the central bank to spend hundreds of billions of dollars in reserves to prevent the slide from turning into a slump.

The most interesting of the facts presented are that Overseas Direct Investment (ODI) by Chinese in December fell almost 40% from a year earlier to $8.41 billion, the lowest monthly level in 2016.

In January, overseas property purchases by Chinese corporations plunged. In one case, a Chinese investor was unable to get permission from authorities to exchange yuan into $30 million to close a U.S. deal, a consultant involved in the project said. The planned $100 million investment in a U.S. residential property portfolio fell through.
"Sellers nowadays will request certain proof," said Jeffrey Sun, a Shanghai-based partner at the legal practice of Orrick, Herrington and Sutcliffe. "From the sellers' side, the worry is justified."
Reuters goes on to outline how fund managers that help Chinese investment abroad are "freaking out" and are searching for creative ways to circumvent capital control regulations.

But perhaps the best part of the article is the ending, which turns to the Village on the Edge of the Rainforest for reassurance and I'm sure will warm the hearts of all local real estate agents... and infuriate many frustrated with government complacency:
"Chinese conglomerate HNA Group announced about $20 billion in outbound deals last year. Thomson Reuters data shows it raised at least $17.05 billion in loans abroad in 2016. Overall, China's outbound investment hit a record last year but could have been much higher, said the Rhodium Group, a consultancy that tracks direct investment from China. It said a record 30 deals worth $74 billion and involving Chinese companies were cancelled in the United States and Europe in 2016.
"Right now everybody is thoroughly freaked out by capital controls," Daniel Rosen, a Rhodium partner and adjunct professor at Columbia University, said. Still, on Vancouver's upscale West Side, a neighborhood popular with foreign buyers where the price of homes runs in the millions of dollars, realtor Tom Gradecak was less worried about Chinese demand. In the past, Chinese investors have tended to find ways around capital controls, he said. "It won't take them long," he said. "The people that really want to come here, I don't think it's going to stop them."
Of course Gradecak would say that. Krusty just gutted the Foreign Buyers Tax to help make that happen, didn't she?


Click 'comments' below to contribute to this post.

Please read disclaimer at bottom of blog.

Thursday, February 16, 2017

So how come we haven't heard much about the Chinese New Year home buying spree this year?

So it's mid February and usually the real estate cartel is barfing out stories about how Chinese have come over to our shores on home buying trips for their kids.

It's become an annual tradition to hear this crap.  Here's just a couple of twitter posts from 2015/2014 to illustrate (click image to enlarge):

And with Premier Krusty gutting the Foreign Buyers Tax at the end of January (presumably it's news of this glorious move that's in those little red envelopes above), expectations soared that Cam Good's yellow helicopter might once again fly over the Lower Mainland.

In fact the Real Estate TV Network (RETV)... err... Global BC announced the wet coast's annual heralds of spring just three weeks ago...

Said Global BC:
"Vancouver’s slow-churning real estate market might see a slight uptick next week due to an influx of Chinese New Year vacationers. 
The Chinese national holiday – celebrated widely in Vancouver and around the globe – begins Friday night with a week-long holiday. Many take the time off as an opportunity to travel abroad. Last year, six million Chinese left the country for vacation., a China-based website for international real estate, says a quarter of Chinese consumers surveyed plan to travel internationally during Chinese New Year, with 42 per cent of those saying they plan to shop for property while away. In total, just under 11 per cent of all people surveyed said they’ll spend the holiday property hunting. 
The website also surveyed 163 realtors in Canada and found 17 per cent of international agents and 16 per cent of Canadian agents had been contacted by buyers who plan to visit during Chinese New Year. 
“We also see Vancouver getting a steady stream of Chinese visitors seeking a ‘lung cleansing’ holiday,” Charles Pittar, CEO of, said. “Canada is a top-five country for these trips. Other top lung-cleansing spots are Japan, Thailand, Australia and Switzerland. One-half billion Chinese were affected by hazardous smog this winter. They come to Vancouver for clean air, among other things.”
So how has the 'lung cleansing' gone so far this year?

Not that we have heard it on RETV Global BC, but reports are that Chinese New Year Sales of Vancouver Real Estate Are Down 78%.

Now besides debilitating Cam Good, an 80% drop in sales is nothing short of devestating. But the  drop in single family home sales - the bread and butter of the foreign Asian market - is even more spectacular. As the above article notes, "Sales of detached homes had the largest drop during this Chinese New Year vs the years prior. Just 119 sales were logged this year, an 87.28% decline from last year."

Yikes. And it's not just the detached market. Chinese New Year Condo sales are reported to be down 72% and townhouse sales down 78%.

Rumour amongst some agents is that pressure is being applied to the BC Liberals to cut what remains of the Foreign Buyers Tax, currently sitting at 15%, to something much lower.

We will see what happens next.


Click 'comments' below to contribute to this post.

Please read disclaimer at bottom of blog.

Wednesday, February 15, 2017

Wed Post #2: The Vinyl Cafe is closed. RIP Stuart McLean

If you ever browse the radio dial and have come across the CBC, you have invariably heard Stuart McLean and the Vinyl Cafe.

The Vinyl Cafe is an hour-long radio variety show hosted by Stuart that is broadcast on the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation's radio service and is syndicated to approximately 80 U.S. public radio stations through Public Radio International. The program is also available as a podcast, although the podcasts are usually just McLean's stories for studio episodes because of copyright restrictions on recorded music. CBC Radio also currently airs a weekday afternoon program, under the title Vinyl Cafe Stories, which consists of two previously recorded Dave and Morley stories per episode.

The show features essays, fiction and music; while frequently humorous, the weekly programs are also often wistfully nostalgic. The live episodes often begin with Stuart reciting a complimentary description of the venue's community about its character and history. The show also endeavours to introduce listeners to new Canadian musical talent, through playing recordings in studio episodes and performances in the live audience ones.

A major feature of many of McLean's shows are the "Dave and Morley Stories", which feature a fictional Toronto family. The name "Vinyl Cafe" refers both to the show's musical content and the fictional record shop owned by McLean's character Dave. This aspect of the show is priceless and if you ever get a chance to listen to "Christmas At The Turlington's", you'll never let a Christmas season pass without it being part of your holiday ritual.

The Vinyl Cafe stopped touring and producing new episodes following McLean's diagnosis with melanoma in November 2015. On December 13, 2016 McLean announced he required a second round of treatment, meaning further delay in producing new episodes, and that repeats of past shows would stop airing on CBC Radio One effective January 2017 to "make room for others to share their work on the radio."

Moments ago CBC announced that Stuart McLean has passed away. A truly iconic voice of Canadiana has been silenced and will be missed.

RIP Stuart. You brought joy, humour and the occasional life reflection to the airways.  Thank you.


Click 'comments' below to contribute to this post.

Please read disclaimer at bottom of blog.

Wed Post #1: Is Horgan as incompetent as Adrian Dix?

A few years back we criticized the BCNDP: before the election for choosing a Dix - a candidate the electorate would have difficulty voting for; and after the election for choosing Horgan - a candidate who we've suggested wasn't the right person for the job if the BCNDP wants to form the next government.

We see little today to alter that impression.

As you will recall our current Premier, Krusty, adeptly remade the BC Liberals after the resignation of Gordon Campbell and leveraged the built in weaknesses that Dix brought to the table as the BCNDP candidate in the last election (his inherent ties to the corrupt Glen Clark government) and swept to a victory almost no one saw coming on election night. A victory on par for shock value that Donald Trump recently executed over Hillary Clinton.

Four years later, Krusty had seemly failed to heed the lessons of the Gordon Campbell implosion and - until last summer - looked destined for a loss in the upcoming May Provincial elections.

In early 2016 the BC Liberals were being hammered by the BCNDP's David Eby.

Eby is a relative newcomer and a bit of a rising star. He first shot to prominence when he was elected the BCNDP MLA for Vancouver-Point Grey in the 2013 provincial election shocker. In an upset victory for the ages, victory was tempered for Krusty by the fact Eby actually defeated her in Clark's own affluent west side Vancouver riding by 1,063 votes.

Krusty was forced to get into the house through an Okanagan by-election months later.

Since then, as housing critic, Eby has masterfully leveraged the havoc that massive worldwide excess credit is wreaking on the Lower Mainland.

This is no small accomplishment considering it's the policies of the Bank of Canada, CMHC and federal government that are to blame, not the BC Provincial Government.

But inaction by Krusty to do what she could to mitigate the damage was creating a rising tide of public resentment. Eby acurrately painted the BC Liberals as being in bed with their Real Estate Development cronies and tied that connection into exacerbating the Vancouver situation.

It struck a chord with the public and Eby was making massive inroads into the BC Libs political support.

Some even wondered if Eby's performance was Leader worthy.

Krusty responded - big time. In a move that astonished even this humble scribe, the BC Liberals imposed a 15% Foreign Buyers tax. Krusty read the mood of the people and moved with lightening speed to enact a significant policy change.

It was roundly cheered by many - both as significant and potentially effective.

By mid September, 2016 the BC Liberals were able to ride the benefits of both a runaway housing market and their attempts to contain it. They announced that, "the B.C. government had raked in $2.2 billion in revenue from the property transfer tax and the new 15-per-cent tax on foreign buyers of Metro Vancouver homes."

That’s a billion dollars more than the government had projected.

As the National Post noted, "That enormous windfall caused Liberal MLAs to break out into a spontaneous conga line through the legislature. Finance Minister Mike de Jong was forecasting a surplus of $1.94 billion, up from an earlier projection of $264 million. He then announced that $500 million from the property tax would fund a housing affordability program and another $400 million would go into the B.C. prosperity fund “as a legacy for future generations,” he said. And this, for the cherry on top: The surplus allowed the government to scrap a planned four-per-cent increase in medical service plan premiums. It wasn’t as tasty a treat as an announcement to revamp or scrap the loathsome MSP entirely would have been. But it did make the medicine go down more easily."

Krusty had neutered the BCNDP criticisms and turned the tide heading into the May 2017 Provincial election.

But in the last three weeks there has been an astonishing about face in the BC Liberal position. Faced with a total collapse in real estate sales (luxury sales down 91% and Vancouver home sales plunged 40%) Krusty has been under enormous pressure to undo the steps she took last September.

Finally she cracked, backtracked and bowed to the pressures of the Real Estate Developers - to the major donors to BC Lib political coffers.

So where is David Eby as this happens? He has been all but invisible.

And now as Toronto housing market starts replicating the excesses seen in Vancouver, the Bank of Montreal publicly declares that Toronto's housing market in a bubble.

And what is a bubble as per BMO economist Douglas Porter?;
“It’s when prices become dangerously detached from economic fundamentals and start rising strongly simply because people believe they will keep rising strongly, encouraging more buying."
That's a definition that describes Vancouver to a tee.

So here you have Canada's major banks finally calling the situation for what it is. And in the midst of it all, Krusty and the BC Liberals are throwing gasoline on a raging fire by gutting the 15% Foreign Buyers tax and introducing the new 'first time homebuyers' giveaway. And it appears to be directly linked to threats by BC Real Estate Developers to yank political donations.

Why isn't David Eby front and center holding the BC Liberal's feet to the fire over this?

You have to wonder if there is a backstory within the BCNDP here.


Click 'comments' below to contribute to this post.

Please read disclaimer at bottom of blog.

Tuesday, February 14, 2017

The gutting of the Foreign Buyer's Tax - might it be Krusty's Achilles Heel?

In our last post we outlined how the our intrepid Premier, Krusty Clark, and the BC Liberals appear to had bowed to pressure from the Real Estate Development community and gutted the 15% Foreign Buyers tax implemented last summer.

Muckraker extraordinaire Bob Mackin advises sources tell him bigwig Developers threatened to withhold huge political donations to the BC Liberals unless they guttered that tax.

Krusty and Co. caved and not only undid the immensely popular move that addressed an out of control real estate market, but they also threw short term fuel on the housing bonfire by introducing a first time home buyers plan that gives young kids the necessary downpayment to get into the housing market. The introduction of this latest moral hazard into the housing mix is just the panacea the condo developers needed to boost a sagging real estate market in clear correction mode.

Combined with the gutting of the 15% Foreign Buyers tax, it will be interesting to see the results at the end of the month.

Just how significantly are the FB tax changes

Another growing name in muckraking media hall of fame is Ian Young, who writes for the South China Morning Post.  In a regular column titled "the Hongcouver" (a title which would have gotten any caucasian crucified by the PC crowd), Young outlines Vancouver’s foreign buyer tax and the work-permit loophole ‘you could drive Highway 99 through’

Young outlines how the rationale for the BC Liberal governments plan to offer exemptions to the tax is sound "assuming that the goal of the tax is to improve affordability by preventing foreign capital further skewing a market that had become detached from local incomes (and is not, say, a pre-election political tactic)."

The theory is that people who live and earn locally should not be unfairly punished.

But when you look at the changes, even the simple minded can see the real intentions of the changes.  As Young writes, "offering foreign-buyer-tax exemptions to work permit holders was a 'Swiss cheese' proposal. “The term ‘work permit’ is too vague to implement the intention (as) foreign-funded buyers pursue permits primarily to escape the tax. There’s a risk that new grads, backed by foreign funds and/or acting as proxies, will dive in."

With less than 100 days to the Provincial election, the BC Liberals are in full campaign mode.  Desperate to preserve political donations, they pragmatically axed the popular move they made last summer by responding to overwhelming public demand to deal with the massive amount of cash (created by the unprecedented excess credit being created in China) sloshing around the world.

But in doing so, the BC Liberals may have created a weakness in their election machine which the politically adept should be exploiting like they were the rebel alliance attacking the Death Star.

The link between the changes and Real Estate Development slush fund money slaps you in the face.  Public anger has not abated from the damaging effects all this malinvestment is having on our communities.

The only saving grace for the BC Liberals may be the inept BCNDP and the mainstream media.

Rather than fully focus on the link, the spotlight has been on a pointless harangue about false allegations of BCNDP computer hacking by the BC Liberals.

No one cares.

And in the process the real scandal that should inflame the voting public is being shoved to the back pages.

It is exactly these types of scandals which ultimately brought down the BC Socreds and Bill Vander Zalm, Glen Clark's NDP, and lead to the resignation of Gordon Campbell.

But BCNDP political ineptitude appears to reign supreme. Horgan has failed to capitalize.

The Vancouver Sun is showing signs of following up, but Krusty is deftly promoting the entry level buyer angle and is successfully throwing up teflon on the silly computer hacking story.

We'd be willing to suggest that throwing the R/E Industry the 'first time homebuyers' bone would have been sufficient to address donation slippage. Gutting the Foreign Buyers Tax and the apparent linkage to massive R/E Developer political donations is their achilles heel.

Will the BCNDP exploit this explosive connection?

The gutting of the Foreign Buyers tax is THE fulcrum that could swing the 2017 election.  

So far the Opposition has failed to capitalize on it.


Click 'comments' below to contribute to this post.

Please read disclaimer at bottom of blog.

Friday, February 10, 2017

Cynicism? Krusty says, "Stand aside Moonbeam and hold my beer!"

Yesterday we made note of the cynical populist political shift of our beloved Village Mayor Gregor 'Moonbeam' Robertson as he responded to the 2016 Census Data revelation that there were twice as many 'unoccupied' homes in Vancouver as the City's survey had found in mid 2016.

Said Moonbeam, “Seeing data that shows there may be even more underutilized homes than BC Hydro suggests gives us more reason to aggressively move on the empty homes tax, and other measures that will help bring homes back within reach to residents in all corners of the city."


Course, such exhortations are a little hard to swallow given his mid year pronouncement that he was against any suggestion of a housing tax targeting non-residents.

But is that real cynicism? Enter the BC Liberal's shouting "hold my beer!"

In July 2016 the BC Liberal's weren't afraid to support a housing tax targeting non-residents. In a surprising move, our beloved Premier Krusty Clark boldly declared a 15% tax targeting foreign buyers and implemented it without much warning.

Now everyone and their dog in the real estate industry (except this dog, of course) was feeding the public the line that foreign buyers were such a small portion of the market that all the fuss about them was a non-issue.

We all knew it was bullshit, but you have to wonder if the BC Liberals thought the tax would be a simple vote-getter without fully appreciating the reality of the situation.

Because the tax had an immediate impact.  A massive immediate impact.

By the end of January 2017, real estate sales in the Village on the Edge of the Rainforest fell off a cliff. Luxury sales were down 91% and Vancouver home sales plunged 40%. The market was cratering.

Did we mention a provincial election is less than 100 days away?

It didn't escape the attention of muckraking reporter extraordinaire Bob Mackin. Bob put his ear to the ground and heard that wealthy developer donors were letting it be known to Krusty, Shrimp de Jong et al that political donations would dry up if they didn't address this catastrophe.

Such news was highly disconcerting to the BC Liberal accountants.

And just who are these $100K+ donors from Feb 2016 that Mackin refers to?

In a recent article, Mackin outlines how the BC real estate development community funnels massive amounts of cash to the BC Libs.

Chronicling one fund-raising extravaganza in February 2016, Makin noted:
The Feb. 26, 2016 haul was thanks primarily to eight individuals and entities that kicked-in a whopping $1.1 million:
  • $200,000 x 2=$400,000: John Redekop Construction and his cousin Peter Wall’s 2300 Kingsway Residences. 
  • $100,000 x 7=$700,000: Peter Redekop, Peter Wall’s PWO Investments and Wall nephew Bruno’s BJW Investment; Townline Homes owner Rick Ilich; Rossano De Cotiis’s RPMG Holdings; Berts Electric; and Seaspan ULC.
Those high rollers are no stranger to writing big cheques to the BC Liberals. Six months before the last election, some of them also injected six-figures into the BC Liberal kitty.

Peter Redekop — whose donations since 2005 now stand unofficially at $609,800 — gave $150,000 on Nov. 8, 2012. His brother John Redekop ponied up the same amount on the same day as a similar windfall from other real estate and construction concerns. 
Also contributing to the party’s Nov. 8, 2012 haul of $833,728 were: Rob Macdonald ($101,200); Intertech Construction Managers/ITC Management/ITC Services ($75,000); Townline Homes ($55,000); Holborn Developments/TA Management and Dayhu Investments ($50,000 each) and Francesco Aquilini ($23,375). The Sheraton Vancouver Wall Centre Hotel donated $4,700. 
Peter Wall and Bruno Wall each gave $150,000 on Nov. 23, 2012, when the Liberals counted another $829,780 in donations. Along with the $300,000 from the Walls came $40,000 from Hassan Khosroshawhi and $20,000 from Colin Bosa.
So it comes as no great surprise (albeit highly disappointing) that with the threat of having the taps turned off on this massive amount of cash that the BC Liberals blinked.

Thus, on Jan. 29, Krusty suddenly announced during Chinese New Year that the BC government would be amending its tax on foreigners buying property in Metro Vancouver. Clark says the levy will be lifted for "those who have a work permit and pay taxes in B.C., in order to encourage more people to come to the province."

The slight change to the Foreign Buyers tax was promoted as a minor adjustment to make the tax fairer so British Columbia can continue to attract the best and brightest to BC.

But given Mackin's revelations about the behind the scenes threats of withholding political donations as the province counts down to what could be another extremely close Provincial Election, it's hard to see the move as anything but selling out to the development community.

Next we will outline just how significantly the BC Liberals have gutted the tax.


Click 'comments' below to contribute to this post.

Please read disclaimer at bottom of blog.

Thursday, February 9, 2017

Mayor Moonbeam Responds To Empty Home Census Data

As outrage grows that there could be as many as 25,502 empty homes in the city, according to the 2016 Canada Census, Vancouver Mayor Gregor Robertson appears to have come out swinging to defend the denizen's of the Village on the Edge of the Rainforest.

“In a housing crisis, it’s unacceptable for so much housing to be treated as a commodity,” said Robertson in a statement. “Housing is for homes first, and as investments second.”

Umm... err...? We'll come back to that.

As you know by now, the 2016 Canada Census released data yesterday which counted 309,418 private dwellings in Vancouver in 2016 – but only 283,916 of those were occupied by usual residents. By comparison, the 2011 census counted 286,742 private dwellings in Vancouver, with only 264,573 of those occupied by usual residents – a difference of 22,169.

That's a stunning increase at a time that the real estate developers are clamouring for increased density to deal with the housing crisis (or as we call it the malinvestment in real estate as a commodity creating a 'housing bubble').

Now “occupied by usual residents” refers to a home where people live permanently. The 25,502 not included in that number were occupied by people who usually live outside Canada on the day of the census or were totally unoccupied.

Adding to the kerfuffle is the fact that last year Gregor's own staff had used BC Hydro data to conclude there are only 10,800 year-round empty homes in Vancouver.

So what did Mayor Moonbeam have to say about this, ummm, contradiction?

“Seeing data that shows there may be even more underutilized homes than BC Hydro suggests gives us more reason to aggressively move on the empty homes tax, and other measures that will help bring homes back within reach to residents in all corners of the city,” he said.

Ah yes, the empty homes tax.  Now... is this the same Mayor Robertson who, back in July 2016, took this position?

Says Robertson today, “the City won’t sit on the sidelines. Vancouver will continue to do all it can to maintain and protect affordable homes, and pursue all tools available to ensure the best use of all our housing.”

All that it can? Spoken like a true populist politician.


Click 'comments' below to contribute to this post.

Please read disclaimer at bottom of blog.

Wednesday, February 8, 2017

Census Stats showing little or no population growth - and a massive variation in COV empty home data

So the 2016 Census data was released today and created quite the bit of commotion on Twitter this morning.

While most municipalities in the region are showing moderate population growth, certain areas are showing no growth whatsoever.  West Vancouver is the fastest shrinking city in the Lower Mainland.

West Van’s population fell 2.1 per cent in 2016. The City of North Vancouver and District of North Vancouver grew by 0.6 per cent and 0.3 per cent respectively, well below the average growth rate in Greater Vancouver, which was 1.6 per cent. 

Vancouver's west side is stagnant as is Richmond's.

Now all of this data is curious because the narrative has been that everyone is moving here and that is what is driving our housing prices through the roof. But BC doesn't crack the list of the top 3 provinces for population growth (Alberta 18%, Saskatchewan 6.3%, and Manitobia 5.8%).

More significantly Census data estimate over 25,500 unoccupied homes in Vancouver... a number DOUBLE the City of Vancouver estimate.

Look for the real estate cartel to immediately start it's media spin to defend it's push for higher density and rezoning.  We'll see if that's the big theme in the coming days.

Meanwhile, check out this humorous Craigslist post for west side Vancouver accommodation...


Click 'comments' below to contribute to this post.

Please read disclaimer at bottom of blog.

Tuesday, February 7, 2017

Vancouver Housing Bubble Month in Review video

A few days ago we shared a new weekly video on youtube that showcases weekly news and tweets from Twitter on the Vancouver Real Estate bubble. 

They've put out a 'month review' video as well. Their handle on twitter is @VanRE_Week_Rev


Click 'comments' below to contribute to this post.

Please read disclaimer at bottom of blog.

Sunday, February 5, 2017

January 2017 Real Estate Stats are out, will Chinese New Year resuscitate the market?

The Real Estate Board of Greater Vancouver (REBGV) announced the January results at the end of last week and you can read their official press release here.

So, officially, home sales crashed 40% last month on a year over year and were down a dramatic 11% from what is normally one of the slowest months of the year.


Only 444 detached houses sold. That's an almost 60% drop from January 2016. Meanwhile new listings are up 7% and total listings are up 14%.

Normally this is where Real Estate agents rush in and say, "no worries. February is Chinese New Year... which means lots of wealthy foreign buyers."

But here's where it gets sticky. The number houses sold worth upwards of $3 million+ has plunged 79% lower. And there's a current supply of almost four years on hand based on current sales numbers. In houses valued over $5 million there’s a five-year supply. Worse, 91% of all the sales in January were for less than asking.

Whether you blame it on the BC Government's Foreign Buyers Tax or not, the reality is that the number of foreign buyer's looking for Vancouver’s luxury real estate has declined dramatically. According to the most recent numbers from B.C. Ministry of Finance, sales of homes over $3 million declined by a whopping 91% from the July peak. Only 8 luxury properties were bought by foreign buyers in November. Curiously November is the last data point that was published. The MoF seems to have skipped reporting for December which suggests it was even worse than November.

Meanwhile realtor Ross Kay advises that the Average Purchase Price of Vancouver real estate plunged a dramatic 19.2% last month and that over 84% of all homes listed for sale failed to sell. 

One of the things that drew many wealthy Foreign Chinese buyers to Vancouver was it worldwide reputation for being a housing casino with almost guaranteed gains the last few years.  Even if they wanted to catch a falling knife by buying right now, you can be sure any offers are going to be cut throat low.

High expectations are riding on the BC Provincial Government's softening stance to the Foreign Buyers Tax.

We will see next month if it's enough to turn things around.


Click 'comments' below to contribute to this post.

Please read disclaimer at bottom of blog.

Thursday, February 2, 2017

Thur Feb 2nd Post #2: Vancouver Housing Bubble Week In Review

From the email bag, a new weekly video on youtube that seems to showcase weekly news and tweets from Twitter on the Vancouver Real Estate bubble. Their handle on twitter is @VanRE_Week_Rev


Click 'comments' below to contribute to this post.

Please read disclaimer at bottom of blog.