Thursday, February 4, 2010

The world and it's view of Vancouver

I have lived in this city for almost 40 years now.

And there is one thing that has always stood out for me... and that is the dramatically different perception you can have of this city based on the way you travel to the downtown core.

Drive down Granville or Cambie Steet, and the city rises up on a sunny day as a spectacular jewel nestled against the mountains.

Drive along Kingsway or Hastings, and the city is a slum.

That dichotomy will take on mythic proportions in the coming weeks.

I can't find the link right now, but I read one account of a journalist visiting Vancouver and he talked about his anticipation in seeing this fabulous city. But leaving his hotel in Burnaby, he would drive down Kingsway and loop around the downtown eastside, never finding the Vancouver of the travel magazines.

I know exactly what he means.

Next week NBC will broadcast Vancouver to the world. Now, Dick Ebersol (of NBC Sports) has already made it clear that the main network of the NBC will do nothing but display Vancouver in all it's stunning glory. NBC does that with every host city.

But contrast that approach with this article from MSNBC.

For those who think the Olympics will be a non-stop real estate advertisment for the Village on the Edge of the Rainforest, this is a taste of what many media outlets will be reporting this week.
  • Canada’s Olympic city has notorious skid row
    Vancouver’s darker side emerges from district known as ‘Pains and Wastes’

    (note to NBC headline writer: that's 'Pain and Wastings' - the writer gets is right in the article)

    VANCOUVER, British Columbia - Five blocks away from the venue for Vancouver's Olympic opening ceremonies, four grizzled addicts huddle in the rain, injecting themselves with heroin behind a trash bin.

    Welcome to Downtown Eastside. Here, life is gritty, volatile and the slightest misstep can invite brutal retaliation.

    "It's a jungle," said Glen, a 49-year-old heroin addict who goes by the street name Trouble. "You want to get out of here."

    As Vancouver prepares for the Olympics and the descent of the world's media, the Downtown Eastside remains a huge problem — 15 square blocks of despair, squalid rooming houses and alleys populated by thousands of addicts, the homeless, the mentally ill and the drug dealers who prey on them.

    This neighborhood is the most concentrated drug and poverty ghetto in North America, with high use of heroin, cocaine and methamphetamine, according to criminologist Benedikt Fischer of Simon Fraser University. It's also the only place in North America where drug addicts can shoot heroin into their veins at an officially sanctioned injection site.

    'Pain and Wastings'

    At the center of the neighborhood is a neoclassical building endowed by philanthropist Andrew Carnegie in 1903. Behind it, dealers and pimps hawk drugs and women in a filthy alley. And on its front steps is Vancouver's largest open-air drug market, at the intersection of Main and Hastings streets— dubbed "Pain and Wastings" by locals.

    Across the street is Vancouver's biggest police station. Police Const. Lindsey Houghton said officers often find themselves in the role of social workers while continuing to target the drug trade. About 49 percent of Downtown Eastside calls are related to mental health, according to the Vancouver Police Department.

    "It's a tremendous challenge that goes beyond the traditional scope of policing," Houghton said.

    The International Olympic Committee's bid evaluation team didn't see the Downtown Eastside when it assessed Vancouver's bid in 2003. When it came time to tour Vancouver venues, the IOC's bus took a wide detour around the neighborhood.

    The bid evaluation team did see the scenic but treacherous highway from Vancouver to Whistler, host of alpine and sliding events. While about $500 million has been spent on the road, the Downtown Eastside remains much the same.

    As they did in 2003, welfare recipients still line up once a month to receive their welfare checks. Welfare Wednesday is known as Mardi Gras in the area, the recipients called "two-day millionaires." Needle exchange staff work on the welfare lines.


    The area gained international attention when pig farmer Robert Pickton was arrested in 2002 and charged with the deaths of 26 prostitutes and addicts from the Downtown Eastside, in what police say is Canada's worst serial murder case. He killed and butchered them at his suburban farm. Some remains he fed to pigs. The rest went to a rendering plant.

    Mona Wilson's head, hands and feet were found in a bucket at Pickton's farm. Her brother, Jason Fleury, called the Downtown Eastside a time bomb and accused officials of doing nothing to defuse it while spending millions on the Olympics.

    "It's crazy. It's insane," Fleury said.

    Prostitution rights activist Jamie Lee Hamilton said little has been done to curb violence against prostitutes since Pickton's arrest.

    "There is this perception that all the violence ended when Pickton was arrested," Hamilton said. "We know it's hunting grounds down there, and we're doing nothing about it. The women, the men and the transgendered are living prey."

    Due in part to rampant intravenous drug use, the area's HIV rate is the worst in the developed world, said International AIDS Society president Dr. Julio Montaner. The HIV rate qualifies the Downtown Eastside for World Health Organization epidemic status, he said.

    Montaner said the combination of drug and health programs as well as housing initiatives are beginning to slow the crisis. But progress may be halted by the increasing violence of Vancouver's drug trade, as cocaine prices skyrocket in the wake of a Mexican drug-cartel crackdown.

    Critics allege the Downtown Eastside will be sanitized during the Games under recently passed legislation that allows police to force the homeless into shelters in cold weather. That would violate bid assurances, they say.

    "Nobody has a right to move those people simply to accommodate a better visual image for the Olympics," said provincial legislative housing critic Shane Simpson.

    Vancouver Organizing Committee vice president of sustainability Linda Coady said the issue has nothing to do with the organizing committee, and that VANOC's interest is what goes on inside Games' venues.

    "Outside is the domain of the Vancouver Police Department," Coady said.

    Meanwhile, the safe injection site in the Downtown Eastside is the busiest in the world, with about 500 supervised injections a day, according to Insite supervisor Russ Maynard. Addicts shoot up at 12 booths with mirrors on the walls so that nurses on a raised platform can see them.

    Maynard said by the time an addict gets to the Downtown Eastside, they are totally dysfunctional. Even trying to get help is hard, he said, as pay phones are used constantly to make drug deals.

    "You could get beat up for tying up a phone for five minutes," he said.

    He said 90 percent of people using Insite have Hepatitis C. The national rate is less than one percent.

    Insite has operated for six years under an exemption from Canada's health laws. The federal government's attempt to close Insite ended Jan. 15 when the British Columbia Court of Appeal ruled addicts had a constitutional right to health care. Whether the case winds before in the Supreme Court of Canada remains to be seen.

MSNBC has taken a realistic, cold, hard look at the real downtown Vancouver. The view that so many locals simply refuse to acknowledge and put blinders on for.

Somehow I don't imagine excerpts of the MSNBC story making it's way into any Bob Rennie literature on the Woodwards development.


Click 'comments' below to contribute to this post.

Please read disclaimer at bottom of blog.


  1. Hmmm... just what I was thinking last night.

  2. I had the pleasure of visiting Vancouver in 2006 on business.
    I found the panhandlers quite agressive. No change was not an answer. When I did give some chump change, I would ask where all the action was and everytime I was referred to Davies Street.
    One hippie lady had a sign that stated she needed money for beer. You gotta love the honesty, so I gave her some on the condition she wouldn't spend it on something stupid like food.
    Overall I thought everything was expensive. The best and cheapest entertainment I saw, were two bums fighting in an alley during lunch time. If memory serves me right, the little guy lost.
    Other then that, Vancouver is all eye candy. Very beautiful.